Pistill

Humanity Needs Humanities — Timothy Harfield

Humanity Needs Humanities — Timothy Harfield

Tell us briefly about yourself and your work. 

I operate Felice Mosca Press, an independent scholarly book publisher dedicated to the ideas and tradition of Giambattista Vico. 

I’m drawn to intellectual misfits. Vico is an excellent example of someone whose ideas were untimely while he lived, and who has never really been embraced as a major figure in the history of philosophy. He’s quite strange, providing creative fodder for the like of Joyce, Borges, Jünger, and many others that you wouldn't expect. 

For me, however, Vico is not simply a curiosity. Instead, he represents a road less travelled, an alternate path to our Cartesian modernity. And he represents a way for us to rethink our humanity at a time when our self-understanding as humans is being attacked by artificial intelligence (AI) on the one hand, and an increasingly nuanced understanding of nature -- and animals in particular -- on the other. As AI becomes increasingly capable, and we come to appreciate just how animal we are (and how humane animals are) we are faced with an important question: what's left?

Descartes, along with Hobbes, Grotius, and the rest of the Natural Law tradition grappled seriously with a similar problem. The growth and advancement of civilization hinged on a shared belief in 'Big Gods.' The Big Gods were being challenged by the advance of Reason, which many thinkers rightfully understood represented a threat to the moral world. If God was necessary to secure the kind of cooperation within large social groups that was so necessary for civilization to emerge, an erosion of those beliefs represented a major risk: without God, what is there to prevent a reversion back into tribalism, and potentially even back into the forest itself?

It was out of this moment that two concepts were created as co-existing alternatives: the self, and society. 

Sociologists have, from time to time, tried to claim Vico as a founder of their discipline (he did, after all, propose a science of culture 150 years before Auguste Comte). However, as I have argued elsewhere, Vico never actually conceptualized the social in a way that would allow a science of society to emerge. On the face of it, he never gives up on theism. The idea of Divine Providence, in Vico, does far too much work. 

It’s easy to want to discount Vico as either a theist or a proto-sociologist. But he’s actually, I think, doing something else. Like Descartes and Grotius, Vico is aware of, and troubled by, the disappearance of Big Gods. But he refuses to take Reason for granted as an obvious solution. If Reason is THE threat to human existence, why would we also look to Reason as the answer?

It's kind of like catching a burglar in the act, and then asking them to remodel your home.

Instead of working to create the future ex nihilo, Vico looks to the past. Instead of looking to replace God with some other object (the self or society), he works to ground humanity in itself. In its relationships. In its stories. A humane future for Vico is not one in which we are constrained by reified objects, but one in which we understand ourselves and others in conversation, and through a shared sense of history that we create together. 

The purpose of the press (named for Vico’s publisher by the same name in 18th century Naples) is to provide a space for people to navigate the future by looking to the past, rediscovering ourselves through a return to that moment in human history when we potentially went off track. 

On the face of it, Felice Mosca Press is about publishing books. But its mission is to help us as humans to navigate our humanity in a posthuman world. The books, then, are merely an expression of the vital conversations and community we are cultivating in response to a moment in which the humanities are under threat by the same forces that threaten our self-understanding as humans. 


What is your understanding of humour, and how does it relate to your work? 

I haven’t thought a lot about humour per se, to be honest. But when I do, I tend to think of it in terms of my memory of reading something from Georges Bataille. I’m probably remembering this wrong, but I think he wrote something sometime to the effect that the reason you laugh when someone falls in a puddle is because it reminds you that it could have very easily been you. 

I take great joy in things that force us to confront our own humanity. I think farts are hilarious (as an undergraduate, I started writing my thesis on the sociology of flatulence. I ended up shifting to write on the topic of love. The bibliography was 80% the same). And I worry about the violence that becomes possible when egotism (which is a disconnection of the self from reality) comes under threat. 

Too many people go to great lengths to hide their humanity. Or to ignore or obfuscate the humanity of others. Laughter is what happens when you let go of ego, embrace your fallibility, and expose your humanity to others.  


What role has cruelty played in your work or understanding of social and cultural phenomena? 

I think a lot about what it means to be Good. I probably don't think nearly enough about what it means to be cruel. 

I think there was a time when I thought I had an answer: probably something about not recognizing the otherness of the Other, blah blah blah. As I've grown older, however, all I really have here are questions. 

  •  What is cruelty?
  • Is cruelty bad? Can it be good?
  • Can animals be cruel? (I operate a horse farm; horses are not always very nice to each other. They pick on each other. They become unnecessarily hostile. Bullying is not uniquely human. The lives of insects are CRAZY!)
  • Is teaching cruel? (Teaching involves changing, and sometimes radically altering, a student’s world. That’s hard. And it’s painful. A good teacher does harm by challenging the realities that students take for granted every day. Is that cruel? Is the absence of this kind of suffering itself a form of cruelty?)
  • Where does cruelty live? (i.e. is it in the intention? The action? The interpretation? The effect? Can I be cruel by accident?)
  • Can AI be cruel?
  • What was the first example of human cruelty?
  • Is cruelty a condition of civilization? (Many myths would suggest it is; many of us think of gossip as cruel, but there is a compelling argument to be made that language actually evolved in order to gossip.)

I'm sure there is an entire literature dedicated to such questions — I'm thinking of you, Giorgio! I should definitely become more familiar with it. 

If cruelty is a uniquely human capability, what does that say about us?


Which classic and recent works would you recommend to readers interested in these themes? 

  • The New Science by Giambattista Vico (Bergin and Fisch translation). If you read nothing else, read the introductory 'Idea of the Work' in which  Vico explains his new science through a description of the work's frontispiece. If you want to learn more about Vico's reception within the Western literary tradition, I highly recommend Vico and Literature by Dustin Peone.  
  • Big Gods by Ara Norenzayan is a compelling account of the religious conditions under which civilization was able to emerge. I would also recommend works by Robin Dunbar, Yuval Noah Harari, and Jared Diamond here, among others. 

One of my favorite books of all time is Who Cut the Cheese? A Cultural History of the Fart by Jim Dawson. It’s out of print, but it’s a delightful read for anyone looking to embrace that fact that, at the end of the day, we’re all just space ships for bacteria… which is pretty funny, when you think about it!